Homemade Ohio charm in sunny Southwest Florida

Custom decorated sugar cookies, mouthwatering cupcakes, cakes, cinnamon rolls & more — made with love by a self-taught baker right here in Fort Myers.

See This Week’s Menu Place an Order
Cottage Bakery Fort Myers / Gateway, FL
Since 2020 Freshly baked to order
Back Home Bakery
Fresh This Week

This Week’s Menu

Limited quantities • Updated every Sunday

Week of …

What’s Coming Out of the Oven

Sunday – Saturday

Quantities are limited. Message us early to reserve your favorites.

Reserve These Treats

A little Ohio heart in every bite

Hi, I’m Amanda — the baker behind Back Home Bakery. What started as a love for making treats for family and friends has grown into a full-fledged cottage bakery right here in Fort Myers.

My specialty is custom decorated sugar cookies. I love turning your ideas — company logos, baby showers, birthdays, or just something fun — into edible art on a soft sugar cookie canvas.

But cookies are just the beginning. We also bake cupcakes, celebration cakes, cinnamon rolls, sourdough breads, and bagels using high-quality ingredients and following Florida cottage food guidelines.

Every order is made with care and a little bit of that Midwestern hospitality I brought with me from Ohio.

— Amanda

What we love creating

  • Custom decorated sugar cookies
  • Signature & specialty cupcakes
  • Celebration cakes
  • Cinnamon rolls
  • Sourdough breads
  • Fresh bagels
  • Corporate & event orders

Ready to order?

A two-week heads-up for larger orders ensures everything is baked to perfection. Smaller orders may be available with less notice — just ask!

Send Your Request

Let’s make something delicious

Tell us about your event, corporate order, or craving. We’ll get back to you as soon as possible to plan the perfect treats.

📞
✉️
📍
Location Fort Myers / Gateway, Florida
Cottage food operation — pickup by arrangement

Order Request

We’ll reply within 1–2 business days. For urgent needs, give us a call.