News!Baking to order this week. Order custom cookies, cupcakes, and cakes for your next celebration!
Photo coming soon
Classic Cookies

Classic Cookies

Seven cookie-jar favorites

Thick, chewy, homemade cookies, the kind you remember from grandma’s kitchen. Ordered by the dozen in the flavor of your choice.

Made to orderOne flavor per dozen
Flavor Choose one
$20 / dozen
1
  • Pickup by arrangement in Fort Myers / Gateway, FL
  • Replies within 1–2 business days
  • Baked fresh in Amanda’s cottage kitchen

Bake sales, lunchboxes, care packages, or just because.

Keep browsing

You might also like

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip CookiesBrown Butter Chocolate Chip CookiesThe cookie jar classic, upgradedSnickerdoodle Classic CookiesSnickerdoodle Classic CookiesPeanut Butter Blossom Classic CookiesPeanut Butter Blossom Classic Cookies

Made in a cottage food operation that is not subject to Florida’s food safety regulations. Questions about ingredients or allergies? Add a note when you order and Amanda will get back to you.